Following Mr. Martin's death in 2003, the so-called "Martin Castle" was sold to Thomas R. Post, a Miami lawyer with Kentucky roots. Renovations began that same year and the name was changed to "The Castle Post." Tragically, the main building caught fire in May of 2004 and the majority of the original structure was destroyed. Before the fire, Post had been renovating the building but was committed to rebuilding it.
Reconstruction was completed in 2007 when Mr. Post opened up a bed & breakfast in the updated building. New additions included luxury suites, a ballroom, library, tennis courts, and a swimming pool. Despite the updates, only guests of the B&B and occasional special events were granted access to the grounds. Castle Post remained a mysterious point of intrigue for locals until it was sold again in 2017 and named “The Kentucky Castle.”